A law banning certain books containing “not age-appropriate” content from being on school libraries’ shelves has been reinstated today (Friday) after a federal appeals court lifted the injunction. The U.S. Court of Appeals for the Eighth Circuit has lifted the temporary block, will now allow the state to enforce the removal of books depicting sex acts and other controversial topics, as well as forbid teachers from promoting or taking part in any curriculum or instruction relating to gender identity or sexual orientation to elementary students through the six grade. The law was approved in 2023, but opposing sides viewed the ruling as violating the First Amendment. State officials disagreed, saying school libraries are required to support school curriculum. The district judge who ruled to place the injunction stated the law was too broad, while the ruling today (Friday) said the initial judge used “a flawed analysis of the law.” Iowa Governor Kim Reynolds applauds the decision, saying, “Today, the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Eight Circuit confirmed what we already knew- it should be parents who decide when and if sexually explicit books are appropriate for their children. Here in Iowa, we will continue to focus on excellence in education and partnerships with parents and educators.” Iowa Attorney General Brenna Bird celebrates the victory in her office’s appeal by saying, “We went to court to defend Iowa’s schoolchildren and parental rights, and we won. This victory ensures age-appropriate books and curriculum in school classrooms and libraries. With this win, parents will no longer have to fear what their kids have access to in schools when they are not around.” Parents concerned about suggested reading materials are asked to bring the issue to their school’s librarian to discuss further action.
